A blog on objective thought in today's irrational, subjective world tackling some of the hardest questions of existence using reason and logic.

It really is bizzare.  I ask people about the lyrics in the songs that they're listening to.... and they don't have a clue what the lyrics actually are.


And if you ask someone to listen to a song, they comment on the melody not the words.  The meaning is a song is the words, the point is the words.  The melody is the vehicle by which the meaning is delivered, but it isn't the point.


And yet, as with everything else, people are going with what makes them feel good and DOESN'T make them think. God forbid anyone actually think about anything! We might be forced to realize that the Federal Reserve just bailed out Bear Sterns and averted a complete economic melt down (See Wall St. Journal for more) the like we've never seen.  God forbid people might have to think about something and actually understand something before acting instead of acting on their ignorant whim!


I wonder how bad things are going to get before people are actually willing to engage their brains?  The scary thing about everything that is happening right now is that people aren't trying to solve the problems, They're trying to just make them go away so that they don't have to think about it, and can claim that "they tried".  As far as I know, at no other time in history has an entire population run from their minds.  And while music is a trivial thing, I think it's all related.  We've created serveral generations of people affraid to think because if they do they'll get stuck in the quagmire of subjectivism and moral equivalence and get confused and then their heads will hurt. 

 

Sad.


Comments
on Mar 29, 2008
And if you ask someone to listen to a song, they comment on the melody not the words. The meaning is a song is the words, the point is the words. The melody is the vehicle by which the meaning is delivered, but it isn't the point.


I disagree vehemently. Ofttimes, it is the melody that carries the message, and the words are useless and perfunctory.

What about instrumental music? Are you for some reason saying it has no meaning? Because its meaning is more broad, more encompassing, more visceral and real than music with words could ever be, because it's not contained - no, constrained - by lyrical contrivance.

To say that the lyrics are the message, the music is naught but a vehicle is foolhardy.

And while music is a trivial thing,


To say that music is trivial is also something I'd disagree with. Music is essential to everyday life - without it, life loses much of its splendor, and most of its meaning.

There's so much more to 'engage your brain' than what you see. Open your eyes, man. They're wired shut by your own musical ignorance.
on Mar 29, 2008
I have partial hearing loss. It seems to be in the mid-range, so yes, I do listen to the music more than the lyrics. And get the lyrics wrong half the time when I do listen to them!

But long before I noticed any loss of hearing, I have always loved Symphony more than OPera, and thus music more than lyrics. A song can suck word wise, but if it has a good tune, I like it.

But I do try to find the lyrics when I really like a song. At least then I know they are talking about Redmen, and not Redrum.
on May 24, 2009

I find it hard to understand what they are saying a lot of the time.....There have been many songs I wish I knew what they were saying.